Save Giotto!

Only a couple of weeks ago I blogged about Giotto’s lost frescoes in Naples which were destroyed by an earthquake in 1456. Now it seems that Giotto’s most important surviving cycle of wall paintings, the decoration of the Scrovegni Chapel in Padua, is in danger of suffering a similar fate – though in this case the danger is man-made: A major building project in the vicinity of the chapel is threatening its stability, and if the current plans are carried out, the chapel’s eventual collapse is a realistic possibility.

Scrovegni Chapel, Padua, Interior with Giotto's frescoes, c. 1305

So earlier today a group of both Italian and international scholars have published a petition calling for construction work to be postponed and the planning of the new building(s) to be reassessed with regards to the delicate condition of the Scrovegni Chapel. To read the petition in its original Italian see here, here or here. I haven’t been able to find an English version of the petition yet,* so voilà, I just made one up myself:

This petition has been initiated by Ales­san­dro Nova, Steffi Roett­gen e Chiara Fru­goni, and has been written by the latter.

Whoever wants to sign it may send an e-mail to pro­fes­sor Ser­gio Co­sta:

Giotto’s frescoes in the Scrovegni Chapel in Padua are running the risk of being destroyed because the highly delicate underlying hydro-geological condition will be inexorably altered by the planned construction of an Auditorium less than 200 metres from the chapel. In the same area, there is also a development plan for a skyscraper of 104 metres in height, and recently there has been completed a parking lot which means that a vast area of ground has been covered in concrete and the soil’s ability to absorb rainfall has been altered.

The results of a study – assigned to three engineers by the City Council – regarding the potential consequences the Auditorium’s construction would have on the surrounding area are indecisive, but they indicate that the deep stratum of the area of the Auditorium is connected with that of the Chapel. It is evident that one cannot entrust the safeguard of an environment to the design engineer of a new work, nor can one entrust him/her with the verdict on the probability that the Auditorium will damage the Chapel immediately or in years to come.

We request that before construction work on the Auditorium begins, the highest safeguard measures be carried out in the Chapel’s subsoil, if possible following an international competition.

How much are Giotto’s frescoes worth, compared to the benefits brought by the new buildings? Let’s not leave it solely to the Paduans to discuss their price, because they are priceless.

–Chiara Fru­goni

Fran­ce­sco Aceto / Ro­berto Bar­ta­lini / Fran­ce­sco Ca­glioti / Laura Ca­vaz­zini / Keith Chri­stian­sen / Ma­ria Mo­nica Do­nato / Vit­to­rio Emi­liani, per il Co­mi­tato per la Bel­lezza / Ju­lian Gard­ner / Carlo Ginz­burg / Ma­ria Pia Guer­mandi, per Ed­dy­burg / Do­nata Levi, per Pa­tri­mo­nio­Sos / Franco Mi­racco / To­maso Mon­ta­nari / Ales­san­dra Mot­tola Mol­fino, per Ita­lia No­stra / Ales­san­dro Nova / Titti Pa­na­jotti, per Ita­lia No­stra Pa­dova / Giu­seppe Pa­va­nello / An­to­nio Pi­nelli / Giu­liano Pi­sani / Se­rena Ro­mano / Steffi Roett­gen /Salvatore Set­tis / Gio­vanna Va­len­zano / Bruno Zanardi

Please be aware that neither Italian nor English is my native language and that geological terminology isn’t my strong suit in any language, so if you spot a mistake in my translation don’t hesitate to let me know – I’ll be happy to correct it.

Please also note that I just made up this translation on a whim and that it hasn’t been approved by the petition’s original authors – I’ll be happy, though,  to substitute it with an official translation of the petition once/if one surfaces.

UPDATE February 7: There is now an official website,, where you can sign the petition online.


* Some writers – especially on Twitter – who have already covered the subject earlier today have linked to this Petition to save Giotto’s frescoes in Padua on Artwatch – this, however is or rather was an entirely different petition and dates back to 1996…

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , , . Bookmark the permalink.

9 Responses to Save Giotto!

  1. Pingback: SAVE GIOTTO! | storie dell’arte

  2. Thank you very much for spreading the Petition, as well as for you unofficial translation.
    And thank you for reporting that Artwatch Petition is old.
    Sorry, there was too much hurry.
    Curiously, the story repeats itself with a new serious Alert.

  3. Pingback: SAVE GIOTTO! [english version] | storie dell’arte

  4. Pingback: Salviamo Giotto! « SaveGiotto

  5. Wow! What scary news. I haven’t been to the Scrovegni chapel yet, so I’m especially (selfishly!) concerned. (I’m also very concerned for the sake of the Western art world, too.)

    I’ll spread the word as best as I can.

  6. Susan Ricci Stebbins says:

    We request that before construction work on the Auditorium begins, the highest safeguard measures be carried out in the Chapel’s subsoil, if possible following an international competition.
    Susan Ricci
    Ted Stebbins

  7. Professor Robin Palmer says:

    Besides being a great artist, Giotto was also a great innovator who anticipated the Renaiissance in his quest for a more naturalistic style. A verse from the song ‘Big Yellow Taxi’ comes to mind: ‘Pave paradise, put in a parking lot.’ The threat to the Scrovegni Chapel must be addressed urgently!

  8. I would do anything to help to save Giotto’s Scrovegni Chapel

  9. Save Giotto, It would be a tremendous lose for ancient fresco’s , Such precious paintings is not be paint anymore .Because we do not have the abillity in time, pigments and technics to paint it, even we would.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s