The most beautiful painting in all of Venice

Over the past few years, I have occasionally busied myself with reading late medieval travel and pilgrimage accounts, hoping that their writers would maybe mention some of the artworks they certainly must have seen during their journey. Unfortunately, this proved to be a (mostly) futile and highly frustrating task. As it turns out, when visiting for example the most splendid ducal palace, late medieval travellers were much more interested in the Duke’s horses or in his artillery than in the Duke’s art collection or the decoration of the palace. And when it came to visiting churches, all they were interested in was relics, relics, relics.

Take for instance the following extract from the account of Duke Friedrich II. of Liegnitz and Brieg who, in 1507, went on a pilgrimage to the Holy Land. On his journey he passed through Venice where he had time to do some sightseeing. What the writer of the account – presumably a cleric from Friedrich’s entourage – offers the reader as a “description of Venice”, however, is basically just a long list of church names and the relics those churches contain:

“Item, in Venice there also is a church called San Zaccaria, and there in the High Altar verily lies the body of St. Zachary who was the father of St. John the Baptist; also there lie two other saints, St. Theodorus and St. Gregorius; also there is a phial with the oil of the holy virgin St. Catherine, and there also is the body of St. Stephen, the pope and martyr. Item, before the nuns’ choir there is an altar wherein lie the holy martyrs Achilleus, Nereus and Pancratius. Item, in another altar the body of a holy virgin and martyr called Sabina, and over that same altar there is some miraculous blood of Christ…”

Giovanni Bellini, Pala di San Zaccaria, 1505, San Zaccaria, Venice (Image © Wikimedia Commons)

However, unlike most other travellers of that era, the writer of that account wasn’t entirely unfazed by the visual pleasures Venetian painting had to offer. And so, his description of San Zaccaria continues with a brief yet telling mention of what today constitutes the church’s most valuable treasure, Giovanni Bellini’s Pala di San Zaccaria (pictured above), which had only been completed a couple of years earlier, in 1505:

“…also in that same church there is a good, beautiful image of our Lady, with the image of St. Jerome to one side and St. Peter to the other, and it is said that in all of Venice there is no painting more beautiful than this…”

Giovanni Bellini, St. Lucy & St. Jerome, Detail of Pala di San Zaccaria, 1505, San Zaccaria, Venice (Image © Wikimedia Commons)

Unfortunately, the writer doesn’t say by whom that claim about the painting’s qualities was actually being made – presumably by the Venetians themselves, one would imagine… But whoever it was, if you ask me, they were absolutely right: There really is no painting more beautiful than this in all of Venice!

Well, that is, of course, with the probable exception of Bellini’s own Frari Triptych:

Giovanni Bellini, Frari Triptych, 1488, Santa Maria Gloriosa dei Frari, Venice (Image © Wikimedia Commons)

Hm, let’s call it a tie, ok?

This entry was posted in Uncategorized and tagged , , . Bookmark the permalink.

2 Responses to The most beautiful painting in all of Venice

  1. Alejandra says:

    What does it makes it beautiful to you?

    • I’m not sure, I guess I just like that sense of tranquil serenity which is so typical for Bellini… And, honestly, it’s not a question I’d actually want to think about too much. You see, as an art historian I usually feel an urge to analyse whenever I look at a painting – any painting, really – and Bellini’s works are among the rare exceptions: I simply enjoy them on an aesthetic/emotional/whatever-you-want-to-call-it level. And starting to ponder what it actually is I like about them might just put me on the road to analysis…

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s